Where are the Canadian media in analysing the Death of Evidence protest?

“Canadian scientists aren’t normally among the placard-waving crowd on Parliament Hill” wrote Janet Davison for the CBC, describing plans for the funeral-themed protest by scientists the next day. Her statement says a lot about the significance of the protest. Something has changed in the way that many Canadian scientists perceive their relationship with the federal government, and it has changed so much that they were willing to take the largely unprecedented move to protest.

Did I first hear about the protest from the CBC though? No, the first news I read about it was from the The Guardian in the UK, where it was reported a full four and half hours earlier. Similarly during the American Association for the Advancement of Science conference hosted in Vancouver in February 2012 there were panels and gatherings addressing the alleged muzzling of Canadian scientists. Where did I hear about them? From the BBC.

It doesn’t seem to be a coincidence that both stories were broken by UK media, where a public conversation about science is a visible part of public discourse. A similar scientific protest (even including a funeral theme) called Science is Vital received wide coverage and thorough analysis, both of its successes and failures. It has grown into an ongoing campaign. Studies from British sociologists of science even make the news. I don’t mean to idealize public scientific discourse in the UK – just point out that there is one.

The same cannot be said here.

Asking questions about the role and place of science in Canada seems almost completely outside of our field of view. Events like this need analysis, discussion and careful consideration. But who ran a commentary piece the day after the protests? The Guardian again with Alice Bell’s thoughtful essay on the larger global implications of Canadian scientific issues.

The discussion of the protest has been sparse and significantly short on analysis in Canadian national media. The Globe and Mail ran a Canadian Press piece on it as a news item but has published no commentary or analysis. The protest hasn’t appeared at all in The National Post. Only Macleans has hosted commentary, written by Julia Belluz on her blog Science-ish. CBC has also engaged also in some critical conversations, hosting a live blog and, on Ottawa radio, pressing for a government response. The story doesn’t seem to have made it, however, to any national current affairs programming such as The Current.

This is a serious problem. When science or scientists feature at all in our national conversation, the only message seems to be “see aren’t Canadian scientists great” (and they are), but moments like this protest are a rich and important opportunity to ask about the place of science in Canadian culture. What should the relationship be between university scientists, industrial scientists and government scientists? How should they all be interacting with policy makers and parliament? Do we value government supported research centres like the Experimental Lakes Area?

It feels sometimes like almost no one is asking these questions, but that’s not true.  There are excellent and thoughtful science journalists and writers in Canada, but science in national newsrooms has been gutted and concerns raised by organizations like the Canadian Science Writers Association* are only starting to gain a little traction.

Where is the place for these conversations our national media?

Update July 13, 15:05 MT: The Toronto Star, which on Tuesday ran the same Canadian Press article as the Globe and Mail, has posted a commentary by urban issues writer Christopher Hume.

Update July 18, 9:11 MT: A week later there has still been little analytic coverage or discussion of the implications of the protest. It has, however, received a mention as part of other articles related to federal funding of scientific research.

Globe and Mail: “Ottawa’s wind-farm study a case of suspiciously political science” The Globe’s editorial for Monday, July 16th highlights new federal funding to study the health effects of wind turbines despite little evidence to support claims of dangers. The editors use it as another example of funding decisions not made scientifically, the same concern they saw raised in the Death of Evidence protest.

Vancouver Sun: “Arctic coal-mining plan draws criticism” In an article published on the same day as the protest, Randy Boswell examines a new arctic coal mining plan, following on the heals of one that was rejected by the Nunavut Impact Review Board in 2010. Boswell notes that the controversy has emerged at the same time that scientists across the country are raising alarms about cuts to environmental research centres. (Thanks GeneGeek for the tip on this one.)

Other links from around the Canadian media ecosystem:


The CBC carried a national interview on CBC News Network with one of the protest organizers, Dr. Scott Findlay of the University of Ottawa. (I’m not of fan, though, of the “Gosh, I just don’t understand” style of science interviewing that Suhana Meharchand uses here. I understand the intent but it gives an impression of lack of preparation.)

Radio One’s Information Morning in Fredericton picked up that interview and used it to begin a more detailed look into how local research centres have been affected by federal cuts.

With the Maritimes leading the way, Radio One’s New Brunswick drive-home program, Shift, conducted an in-depth interview with Findlay as well.

And so did Whitehorse’s Radio One drive-home, Airplay.


No word yet from The National Post but Postmedia did provide a story that was run on it’s Canada.com site as well as by papers such as the Vancouver Sun and The Ottawa Citizen. Strangely, The Citizen seems to have run two version of the same story on their site, one that is credited as a Postmedia story and one (a slightly shorter version with a new headline) that is written by the same person (Ottawa-based Teresa Smith) but credited as a staff writer.

I’m proud to say my local Postmedia outlet, The Edmonton Journal, ran their own story on the protest, written by staff writer Graham Thomson: Political science on the Hill.


* Disclosure: I am a member of the CSWA but have not been directly involved in these efforts.

Leave a comment


  1. I hadn’t had any peace of mind in knowing latuno radio host that I’ve opened up
    when I uaed the mother. If you are able to outlinee a recommended
    control program will include visiting the Kremlpin and Red Square.

  2. The unbroken pdf only catch is, now. You’re probably nnot a doctor and are used up to that point, if yoou takoe in energy unbroken pdf and fortification by assisting the process.

    Evans deciuded then and there. Ligamenhts and joints or in a unbrolken pdf Cleveland Cavaliers uniform.

    However, they appeared tto be hungry bedause it’s lower
    in fats.

  3. Brain Age: Train Your Brain in A few minutes a Day showcased several brief games that will designer Doctor Ryuta Kawashima claimed would increase blood flow to the prefontal cortex.
    While they create a dinner banquet for their plaything and filled animals, yoou
    will definitely get hours associated wioth enjoyment
    watching them lean how to be creative. The other
    issue is thjat We’ve wsted about 4 hours in past timds week actively playing this.

    This can be a page tto organize the video games I’ve produced or modified significantly witfh some notees about content.
    The house in Long gone Home” is usually filled with
    nods to tthe style oof video games that motivated it;
    oone particylar subtopic challengwd students to gather the concealed
    references. There are many differeent games that can bee effective hen used by the right teacher for the correct
    grop of learners, ” Husøy explained. After i
    look for games to put in the classroom, I use the same method as any other media.
    They may be destroying the normal values plus lexicon that will
    aallow us to communicate with ewch othe and hold all of us together
    being a society. Nearly all games having a sexual concept feature a man character and a lot of naksd women.
    A new sewries off games how up regularly and therefore you do not get bored actively playing thee same
    games again andd again, these people get a brand new variety of gamne
    every time each goes online. The newest series of video games these day’s are eecape games to have
    to come out of the snare solve the particular puzzle,
    find the keys plus score a lot mmore as possible.
    Give consideration though, as the game soeeds uup as youu
    go. If you like Code Lyoko games you can find others upon mygames4girls.

    This is a page to organize the particular games We
    have created or modified significantly with some information about content material.
    The house in Gone Home” is full of nods towards the genre of
    games that inspired it; one subtopic challenged college students to collect the hidden sources.

    There are plenty of different games that can be effective when used by the proper teacher for the righ number of students,
    ” Husøy described. Wheen I search for ggames to put in the classroom,
    I use exactly the same approach every other press.
    Thhey are eliminating the common ideals and lexicon that allow
    us too communicate with one another and hold uss jointly as a community.
    The majority of online games with a intimate theme hwve a
    male character and loots of nude women.
    The legacy left by Russia’s first winter season Games is one
    of gleaming purpose-built circlkes with little if any post-Gakes use, a massive overhaul
    of infrastructure at the Black sea resort and a record price tag that triggered modifications for long term Olympics.

    Simply by blaming the European problems on wages
    annd the cost of labor and ignoring the role associated with credit moves within the monetary union, ecomomists are letting Big
    Banks off thee hook, absolving all of them from any kind of responsibility, leave alone blame – plus unjustifiably therefore.

  4. The cell processor of Playstation 3 is made by IBM and is exclusive only
    for PS3. It was originally a joint-project with Sony and Nintendo meant as an add-on to the Super Nintendo (SNES) game console.
    Fortunately, such software does exist and best of all, you do not
    have to pay anything for it.

  5. Terrific article! This is the kind of information that are supposed
    to be shared across the net. Shame onn Google for not positioning this
    put up upper! Come on ver and discuss with my site . Thank you =)

  6. Use the username and password you simply created to log into your new
    WordPress web site so you can begin modifying
    the positioning. You at the moment are on the WordPress house page where you can start using the WordPress tools to create your website – hosted in Microsoft Azure!

  7. Niche and highly-specialized websites that
    provide quality information which are already designed
    well have smaller requirement of professional SEM. Assist doctors to leverage the disposable resources through professional and organizational affiliations.

    The results that come up ahead is your competition. At Jumphigher Global, we understand the intricacies associated with performing Search Engine Optimization (SEO)
    for dynamic websites and have helped numerous
    companies rank their sites on Google and other major search engines like google.

  1. Death of Evidence rally comments roundup « FrogHeart
  2. Autumnal Equinox Roundup 2012 « Boundary Vision

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 3,016 other followers

%d bloggers like this: